Can Israel succeed in ending the presence of UNRWA?

Scotland did not pause ‘funding for the UN agency’— Scottish first Minister

unrwa
UNRWA school in Gaza(File photo: Jordan News)
EDINBURGH — On Sunday, Scotland First Minister Humza Yousaf stated that the Scottish government has not paused or withdrawn aid to UNRWA. اضافة اعلان

In a post on his official account on X, formally known as Twitter, Yousaf said, “To be clear, the government has not paused or withdrawn aid to UNRWA. We have previously provided as much as we can within our financial constraints. We will always seek to do more where we can & urge others to continue to provide aid to the people of Gaza.”

Scotland clarified its stance after news publications reported that it had decided to cease funding to UNRWA following allegations by Israel regarding the involvement of some UNRWA employees in the events of October 7, 2023.

UNRWA's Commissioner-General, Philippe Lazzarini, acknowledged that Israeli authorities had provided the agency with information regarding the alleged involvement of some employees on October 7. However, Lazzarini did not disclose the number of employees implicated or the nature of their alleged involvement, Khaberni reported. 

Despite this, Israel's spokesperson, Elon Levy accused UNRWA of publicizing the news at a time when global attention was focused on the International Court of Justice's (ICJ) order for Israel to prevent genocide against Palestinians and provide more assistance to civilians in Gaza.

Israel's intensifying efforts to dismantle UNRWA
The relationship between Israel and UNRWA has been fraught with tension under various Israeli governments, marked by friction and conflicting agendas. While Israeli officials believed that UNRWA's presence perpetuated the conflict, they also recognized its necessity due to the humanitarian aid it provided to Gaza and parts of the West Bank, which helped maintain stability in those areas.

Over time, Israel's desire to eliminate UNRWA and its role intensified. In 2018, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu called for placing Palestinian refugees under the UN Refugee Agency and ending UNRWA's existence, arguing that it served Palestinian interests and perpetuated the refugee issue.

New opportunity
Israel saw an opportunity to dismantle UNRWA during its war on Gaza, supported extensively by the US and Europe, viewing UNRWA's presence as perpetuating the refugee issue.

Israeli authorities, including Netanyahu, have long accused UNRWA of fueling incitement against Israel. The agency angered Israel during the war by accusing it of targeting civilian objectives, including schools and medical centers.

Moreover, the ICJ, citing UNRWA reports on Palestinian suffering, fueled Israel's desire to eliminate the agency and its role.

Israel's Minister of Foreign Affairs, Yisrael Katz stated that Israel would seek to prevent UNRWA from operating in the strip after the war and urged countries to follow the example of those suspending funding for UNRWA.

Western support
The US, Italy, Canada, Australia, Britain, and Finland swiftly suspended their funding to UNRWA, followed by Germany, the Netherlands, and Finland.

Italian Minister of Foreign Affairs, Antonio Tajani announced on X, formally known as Twitter, that the Italian government suspended funding to UNRWA. Australian Foreign Minister, Penny Wong, stated that they would temporarily suspend payments.

Canadian Minister of International Development, Ahmed Hussen said, “Canada has temporarily paused any additional funding to UNRWA while it undertakes a thorough investigation into these allegations."

The US also announced a temporary suspension of all future funding to UNRWA, which plays a crucial role in aid distribution to civilians in the strip amid the ongoing Israeli war.

According to UNRWA's website, the US was the largest donor to the agency in 2022, contributing over $340 million. The US had previously suspended support for UNRWA during former President Donald Trump's tenure before President Joe Biden reinstated funding.

Right-wing pro-Israel groups in the US and Republicans have long argued for stopping funding to UNRWA, claiming that its monopoly on the Palestinian refugee issue perpetuates the conflict and dependency culture among Palestinians.

Israeli agreement
The Western stance received a positive response from both government and opposition members in Israel despite differences over the war on Gaza.

Israeli Defense Minister, Yoav Galant expressed satisfaction with the US decision, considering it an important step towards holding UNRWA accountable. Leader of the Opposition in Israel, Yair Lapid congratulated the US, Britain, Italy, Canada, Finland, and Australia on their decision to halt funding to UNRWA.

However, the Palestinian Authority (PA) accused Israel of conducting a campaign of incitement aimed at liquidating the agency.

A senior UN official cited by The New York Times expressed concern that UNRWA's loss of funding could rapidly impact its operations, particularly regarding funding for its 150 shelters housing around 1.2 million displaced people in Gaza alone.


Read more Region and World
Jordan News