What if Israel does not comply in ICJ case? Expert weighs-in

International Court of Justice ICJ
(Photo: Twitter/X)
THE HAGUE – In a historic event, Israel will appear for the first time before the International Court of Justice (ICJ) in The Hague, Netherlands, on Thursday in a lawsuit filed against it by South Africa accusing it of committing genocide against Palestinians in Gaza, Al-Mamlaka TV reported.اضافة اعلان

Israel chose retired judge Aharon Barak, former president of the Supreme Court of Israel, to represent it on the ICJ panel of judges in the lawsuit filed by South Africa.

South Africa submitted an 84-page request to the ICJ on December 29, 2023, to initiate proceedings against Israel under the 1948 Genocide Convention., confirming that “Israel’s actions and shortcomings have a genocidal character because they are accompanied by the specific intent required (…) to destroy the Palestinians in Gaza as part of the broader national, ethnic, racial, or ethnic group, the Palestinians.”

Since October 7, Israel has launched a destructive war on Gaza, which has killed over 23,000 people and injured over 58,000. More than 70 percent of them are women and children, and more than 7,000 people are missing under the rubble. This is in addition to the enormous destruction of infrastructure and an unprecedented medical catastrophe.

What if Israel does not comply with the court’s decision?
Dr. Anis Kassim, an expert on international law based in Jordan, said that the ICJ issues two types of decisions: the first is a legal opinion, which is non-binding, and the affected party benefits from it, while the other is a judicial decision in a dispute lawsuit, which is binding, like the lawsuit filed by South Africa against Israel. He explained that if the court’s decision is issued, Israel must comply as it is a member of the Genocide Convention and the United Nations Charter.

Dr. Kassim told Al-Mamlaka TV that the 1948 Genocide Convention punishes the perpetrator (Israel) and the instigator (the US). He pointed out that it is natural for the United States to stand against South Africa’s lawsuit because it “defends its position supporting Israel in the genocide war by participating in sending at least 30 planes carrying military equipment and ammunition in support of the Israeli aggression on Gaza.”

“If Israel insists on not complying with what the court decides in the lawsuit filed by South Africa, the latter goes to the Security Council, which will review the situation and decide that Israel must comply with the decisions of the ICJ as the highest judicial court in the world and an integral part of the UN,” according to Dr. Kassim.

Regarding the possibility of the United States using the veto in the Security Council, Dr. Kassim ruled it out, saying that it would be a “great challenge” to international law, explaining that Washington is a founder of the UN and the ICJ, which is also headed by an American judge.

He added, “If we assume that the US uses the veto, South Africa can, in cooperation with a group of friendly and supportive countries of the lawsuit, request a resolution from the General Assembly to besiege Israel, boycott it, withdraw ambassadors from it, withdraw diplomatic recognition, and prevent Israeli aircraft from entering its airspace, and this means isolating Israel from the world.”

Regarding the integrity of the judiciary in the ICJ, he said, “I have confidence that the judges of the court are honest and credible and come through an election in the UN, and their legal backgrounds will prevent them from immersing themselves in bumps that may not be suitable for their cultural, intellectual, and jurisprudential level.”

Palestinian Assistant Foreign Minister to the UN, Omar Awadallah, confirmed that the decisions of the ICJ are binding on all countries, not only in terms of not committing genocide but also in preventing it and punishing it.

Regarding the court session, Awadallah said that the court’s panel of 15 judges will hear South Africa and its legal team for two hours on the first day, and the session will be adjourned for deliberation. On the second day, the court will hear from Israel, the session will then be adjourned to consider urgent procedures and measures.

The hearings are to be held in the ICJ on January 11 and 12.

Jordan’s role in the lawsuitJordan was the first country to announce its support for the lawsuit filed by South Africa, where Prime Minister Bisher Al-Khasawneh and the Minister of Foreign Affairs, Ayman Safadi, confirmed that the Kingdom would provide the necessary legal documents as soon as the ICJ considers the lawsuit.

Safadi added that the ministry is working on preparing the necessary legal files, as well as coordinating with Arab and Islamic countries.


Read more Region and World
Jordan News